Difference Between AIF, Mutual Funds and PMS – Which One Should You Choose?

In India's rapidly growing investment scenario, options for investors are no longer limited to traditional equipment such as fixed deposits, gold or real estate. With rising income and greater financial awareness, refined investment products such as optional investment funds (AIFS), portfolio management services (PMS), and mutual funds (MFS) are attracting significant attention. Nevertheless, for most investors, the differences between them remain blurred.

At first glance, all three options serve the same objective: professional money management and high returns. But in fact, they work under very different structures, regulatory structures and risk-return profiles. Understanding these differences is not just an educational practice; This is important to make an informed option that matches your financial goals.

Powered by Froala Editor

There has been a remarkable change in India's asset management industry. Mutual funds alone have increased from about ₹10 trillion to 2025 (AMFI data) in 2014 as 2025 (AMFI data)*under management (AUM) to about 60-75 trillions. PMS and AIF, while being small, quickly holding in size, thanks to the rising appetite of high-pure people (HNI) and the offices of the family looking for personal strategies and exposure beyond public markets.

This structural change reflects important realities: investors are no longer satisfied with vanilla returns. They want alpha (outperform).

Investors have a wide range of investment options today, each diet for different -risk appetite, investment horizon and financial purposes. Among them, mutual funds, PMS and alternative investment funds are the major options. They vary greatly in terms of structure, regulation and target investors.

Powered by Froala Editor

Mutual funds represent a collective in terms of pooled investment mechanisms, a sort of safer investment option for where money is pooled from many investors, managed professionally. This consolidated capital is then deployed in a diverse portfolio of securities including stocks, bonds and other financial instruments to achieve specific investment objectives. 

Regulated by SEBI, are structured as a mutual fund trust and other investment avenue determining schemes and funds offer units to investors. They are a foundation stone for retail investors who are demanding professional management and diversification with relatively low minimum investment requirements.

They are ideal for salaried individuals, first investors, or whoever wants to contact in markets without active participation.

But trade is closed standardization. A mutual fund scheme should complete thousands of investors. It cannot personalize strategies or place focused bets. For investors seeking tailor solutions, this is limited.

Powered by Froala Editor

Portfolio management services (PMS) are often described as mutual funds for "big affluent". Unlike other options consisting of mutual funds, PMS provides and aims to cater investors in customized portfolios managed by professional fund managers.

• Minimum Investment: ₹50 lakh (as per SEBI guidelines).

• Ownership:  Investors grab securities directly into their demat account (unlike the pool units in MF).

• Flexibility: Fund managers can design unique strategies and imbalance portfolio based on individual preferences or risk appetite.

PMS's appeal lies in privatization and uniqueness. Investors can select between a discretionary (manager's decision) or non-provision (investor decision) model. PMS managers often run a portfolio centered between 20–25 high-conviction stocks, targeting high alpha.

However, the flip side is high risk and high cost. Return is not guaranteed, and PMS fees (usually 2% management + profit sharing) are significantly higher than mutual funds. PMS works best for investors who have large capital and can face market volatility.

Powered by Froala Editor

Alternative Investment Funds are investment vehicles designed for privately sophisticated investors. These funds invest in alternative asset classes that are often beyond the scope of traditional mutual funds or direct equity/loan investment. AIFs include a comprehensive spectrum of investments including Venture Capital, Private Equity, Hedge Fund, Real Estate and Distributed Assets. 

While regulated by SEBI, AIF usually works under less rigorous criteria than mutual funds, offering more flexibility in investment strategies and potentially targets high returns, which are with computable risk and prolonged lock-in periods. In particular, experts of category I AIFs, often startups, SMEs, or infrastructure experts, target power portfolios with high-proclaimed businesses shaping the future of the Indian economy.

Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) fulfills refined investors seeking high returns, unique market access and more active portfolio management. In India, AIF Framework enables fund managers to invest in asset classes and strategies, such as private equity, venture capital, pre-IPO placement, unlisted SME, startups, real estate and complex derivatives, and traditional mutual funds.

Superior Historical Performance: Indian AIF has recorded mutual funds up to 34% in two years and an average CAGR up to 26% in five years, compared to specific mutual fund returns of 12–15%.** A study also shows that AIF grows faster than mutual funds and PM in five years.

Mutual funds usually charge management fees based on total assets under management (AUM). In contrast, AIF usually charges management fees based on a committed capital or initial investment amount rather than property under management. AIFs usually have a more transparent profit-sharing system that aligns the interests of fund managers and investors.

Mutual funds usually invest at least 95% of their capital, which limits their ability to suit the changing market dynamics. Conversely, AIF can book strategically profitable capital for more favorable opportunities and book real capital, increasing their capacity for high returns. 

Fund Manager Expertise and Due Diligence: AIF managers provide deepest company concentrated field expertise and adequate resources for proper hard work, especially in SMEs like top or opaque markets. This expertise allows AIF managers to identify opportunities and manage risks that can normalize the mutual fund mandate.

A Comparative Snapshot: Mutual Funds, PMS, AIF

Conclusion

India’s investment choices are no longer “one-size-fits-all.” Mutual Funds democratize investing, PMS personalises it, and AIFs unlock opportunities beyond the mainstream.

The decision is less about “which is better” and more about what fits your financial profile. For most, mutual funds remain the backbone. For the affluent, PMS adds flavour. And for the truly sophisticated and big investors that are redefined investment structure, AIFs open a world of alternatives and investment segments itself.

In an era where wealth generation is becoming more accessible and more complex, what becomes crucial is linked to your investment not only with markets but also with your goals, risk appetite and time horizon.

Powered by Froala Editor